Contents
- 1 The Smart Lock Anxiety: The Fear of Trading My Key for a “Smart Brick”
- 2 The Silent Consensus: Why the Encode Plus “Just Works”
- 3 The “Aha!” Moment: The Apple Home Key Experience
- 4 The Context of 2026: Should You Wait for the Schlage Sense Pro?
- 5 The Technical Deep Dive: Thread vs. Wi-Fi (The Battery Secret)
- 6 The Backup Plan: Silencing the Fear of Being Locked Out
- 7 A Quick Word on Installation
- 8 The Bottom Line: Schlage Encode Plus Home Key Review
- 9 What If You Need an Alternative?
The Smart Lock Anxiety: The Fear of Trading My Key for a “Smart Brick”
Tired. That’s the real reason I decided to buy the Schlage Encode Plus.
I didn’t get it because of specs or flashy ads. I got it because I was tired, tired of standing in the rain, wondering if I’d locked the door.
And here’s the funny thing: no matter which blog you read or who you talk to, the answer always seems to be the same, Schlage Encode Plus.
Everybody kept saying the same thing, over and over, and honestly, it started freaking me out.
Let’s be real. When I first started looking into smart locks, I wasn’t worried about losing my keys, I’d already done that a dozen times.
My real fear was dropping three hundred bucks on a fancy gadget that would turn into a useless metal brick on my front door.
You know the drill: a dead battery at the worst possible moment, a Wi-Fi hiccup that locks you out in the rain, or an app that’s more frustrating than a tangled headphone cord.
That anxiety?
It’s what kept me on the fence for months.
I spent countless evenings scrolling through Amazon reviews and Reddit threads.
It felt like a minefield.
Every lock had its horror story: “Battery died after two months,” “Constant disconnects,” “The motor just seized up.”
I realized I wasn’t looking for the smartest lock. I was looking for the most reliable one.
Honestly, I’m not even sure why it took me so long to buy it. Maybe I just needed to hear enough horror stories first.
This isn’t just a product review; it’s me sharing the solution I found to the biggest anxiety in modern home security.
That single focus on reliability kept bringing me back to the Schlage Encode Plus.
This isn’t just a product review; it’s me sharing the solution I found to the biggest anxiety in modern home security.
Even here in 2025, with all the new tech hype, I still think this lock is the safest, most solid bet for anyone living inside the Apple ecosystem.
If you’re an Apple user searching for a reliable smart lock that won’t turn into a “smart brick”, this review is for you.
I tested the Schlage Encode Plus in real life and compared it with Yale, August, and Aqara to give you the honest answer you actually need.
If you want my full list of top picks for 2026, check out my updated guide: Best Smart Locks 2026.
Top Picks Overview
You’re busy, so I’ll get straight to the point. After testing and digging through reviews, here’s the recommendation that truly holds up. If you want the full reasoning, stick with me.
Other cool articles I made for you:
1. Best Smart Locks of 2026 — Tested for Reliability, Security & Real-Life Use
2. Are Smart Locks Safe? A Realistic Look at Hacking, Break-Ins, and Your Real-Life Security
3. The Best Smart Locks That Work with Apple HomeKit & Home Key (An Honest, No-BS Guide)
4. How to Install a Smart Lock (For When It’s Not as Easy as the YouTube Videos
The Silent Consensus: Why the Encode Plus “Just Works”
Schlage has been in the lock game for over a century.
You feel that history the second you pick up the Encode Plus.
It’s heavy.
It’s solid.
It feels less like a flimsy piece of plastic and more like a proper, serious security upgrade.
But For Apple folks like me, the best part isn’t some flashy feature, it’s how quietly it just works with HomeKit and Apple Home Key, like it was always meant to.
I get it. You’ve heard the noise.
We’ve got Matter trying to unify the smart home world, and Ultra-Wideband (UWB) promising to unlock your door before you even touch it.
Schlage even announced the Sense Pro, which will have all that new Matter and UWB goodness.
So, why am I still pushing a lock that’s technically “last year’s model”?
Because the answer is simple, and it’s the quiet truth I found buried in the most honest corners of the internet: the Encode Plus is the one that most consistently “just works.”
Think of it this way:
all that new tech is still in its awkward teenage phase, full of potential, but also full of bugs, delays, and instability.
The Encode Plus?
It’s the seasoned veteran. It’s the gold standard for stability that has already proven its worth in thousands of homes.
My Authority Trigger:
Forget the hype. Even with Matter and UWB finally showing up, the Encode Plus is the lock that has earned the right to be called ‘just works.’
If you value peace of mind over being a tech guinea pig, this is your safe harbor.
If you’re still weighing your options against other top contenders, like the Yale or August, you might want to check out my comprehensive comparison: Schlage vs Yale (2026): Which Legacy Lock Brand Makes the Best Smart Lock?
The “Aha!” Moment: The Apple Home Key Experience
I’ll tell you exactly when this lock won me over.
I had just finished a brutal five-mile run. I was drenched, exhausted, and carrying nothing but my Apple Watch.
I walked up to the door, tapped my wrist against the lock, and heard that satisfying, solid thunk-click.
The door was open. No fumbling for keys, no digging for my phone, no trying to remember a code while my brain was fried.
That was it.
For an Apple user, Home Key isn’t just a feature; it’s the entire reason to buy this lock.
It’s the seamless experience that makes the price tag worth it. If you want to see how it stacks up against other HomeKit options, I broke down the best ones here: The Best Smart Locks That Work with Apple HomeKit & Home Key (An Honest, No-BS Guide).
The Context of 2026: Should You Wait for the Schlage Sense Pro?
I don’t know about you, but me, awkward as I am — sometimes I just lie in bed, staring at the ceiling, overthinking stuff for hours.
I remember it clearly: one of those nights was when I found out the new Schlage Sense Pro was coming, promising Matter-over-Thread and UWB (Ultra-Wideband).
It sounded like the future, right?
My honest take?
I almost waited, but then I realized something crucial: I am not a product tester, and neither are you.
Buying the first generation of a brand-new technology, especially one that controls the security of your home, is a huge gamble. The Sense Pro is exciting, but it needs time to prove its stability, battery life, and reliability in the real world.
I thought the UWB thing would be a must-have, turns out, not really.
Once you have Home Key, it’s hard to care about the next big protocol.
Every new product has bugs. Every new protocol has growing pains.
It’s been there, done that. It’s mature, its firmware is rock-solid, and the community consensus is overwhelmingly positive. Maybe it’s just me, but I trust something that’s been tested for years more than shiny new tech. Especially when it’s literally guarding my front door.
I know, it looks like a lot. But these are the things that actually made the difference for me.
| Feature Comparison: Encode Plus vs. Sense Pro (The Reliability Angle) |
Details |
|---|---|
| Status | Proven, Stable |
| Connectivity | Thread (HomeKit) / Wi-Fi |
| Reliability | Gold Standard in HomeKit |
| Recommendation in 2026 | For peace of mind today. |
If you need a reliable lock today, the Encode Plus is the answer.
If you can wait a year or more for the Sense Pro to iron out its inevitable first-generation kinks, then maybe hold off.
For me, the security of my home couldn’t wait for a promise.
The Safe Bet If you’re like me and prioritize proven stability over future promises, the Schlage Encode Plus is the lock to get right now. It’s the one I chose.
Schlage Encode Plus
Top-tier reliability with seamless Apple Home Key integration. Peace of Mind. It "just works” experience with the ultimate physical key backup.
Pros
- Apple Home Key is a Game-Changer
- Built Like a Tank
- Multiple Backup Plans
- Trusted, Household Name
Cons
- Premium Price Tag
- Potential Weather Sensitivity
- Requires a Strong Wi-Fi Signal
I independently test and review smart home products. When you buy through my links, I may earn a commission — at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Why We Picked It
Top-tier reliability with seamless Apple Home Key integration. Peace of Mind. It "just works” experience with the ultimate physical key backup.
Who It’s For
Apple users who want a trusted, traditional brand.
Specs & Configuration
Remote Access – Lock or unlock your door from anywhere via the app.;
App Control – Manage users, check activity, and receive alerts from your phone.;
Schedule Codes – Create and manage up to 100 custom entry codes.;
Smart Home Ready – Compatible with major smart home systems.;
Voice Control – Works with supported voice assistants for hands-free use.;
Built-in Alarm – Detects tampering or forced entry attempts.;
Battery Operated (No Hardwiring) – Runs on batteries;
easy to install and maintain.
Table Summary: Comparison of key advantages and drawbacks of the Schlage Encode Plus — balancing security, reliability, and convenience.
The Technical Deep Dive: Thread vs. Wi-Fi (The Battery Secret)
This is the most important part of the review that most people skip.
It’s the difference between loving this lock and hating it. It all comes down to Thread versus Wi-Fi.
The Hidden Pain Point: Battery Drain
Let’s talk about batteries.
No one wants to be replacing four expensive AA batteries every three months. That’s a hidden cost and a major pain.
Why does this happen?
Because Wi-Fi is a battery hog. It takes a ton of power for your lock to constantly talk to your router.
Thread is the secret sauce.
The Encode Plus is one of the few locks that supports Thread, a low-power mesh network protocol. If you set up the lock through HomeKit, it will use Thread (assuming you have a HomePod Mini or Apple TV 4K acting as a Home Hub).
This is a game-changer:
- Battery Life: Instead of swapping batteries every 3-4 months, you can easily push that to 6, 9, or even 12+ months. Thread’s low-power design is a massive win for your wallet and your sanity.
- Speed (Latency): Ever had a smart device take three seconds to respond? That’s high latency. Thread’s low latency means that when you tap your watch or ask Siri to unlock the door, the response is almost instantaneous. It’s that speed that makes the lock feel reliable, not sluggish.
| Practical Impact: Wi-Fi vs. Thread on Your Smart Lock | Details |
|---|---|
| Power Consumption | High (Drains Batteries) |
| Battery Life | Months (3–6) |
| Speed (Latency) | Noticeable Delay |
| Stability | Dependent on Wi-Fi signal strength |
So yeah, here’s how I see it: If you are an Apple user, you absolutely must use Thread.
It transforms the Encode Plus from a good lock into a great one.
The Backup Plan: Silencing the Fear of Being Locked Out
What truly sealed the deal for me was the sheer number of backup plans. It’s like Schlage’s engineers were all former lock-out victims who designed a lock specifically to quiet that nagging fear.
This multi-layered approach is the core of its reliability:
- Backup 1: The Keypad: Dead phone? No problem. You still have the illuminated keypad to punch in your PIN. It’s simple, reliable, and always there.
- Backup 2: The Physical Key: This is the big one. Yes, it comes with a traditional physical key. In a world of digital gadgets, having that old-school metal key is the ultimate, non-negotiable guarantee that you will never be stranded. I love the tech, but I love redundancy more.
- Backup 3: The App: You can always check the status and lock/unlock remotely via the Schlage Home app or the Apple Home app. Say you’re at the grocery store and your kid calls saying they forgot their code—you can let them in from anywhere.
This layered security is why I can confidently recommend it.
It directly addresses the number one fear of the smart lock buyer: “What if I get locked out?” With the Encode Plus, the answer is, “You won’t.”
A Quick Word on Installation
I’ve seen enough forum meltdowns to know that a bad installation is the number one cause of smart lock failure.
If the deadbolt doesn’t line up perfectly with the strike plate, the motor has to fight to lock the door. That fighting drains the battery fast and leads to early motor failure.
If you want to make sure your installation is flawless and avoid those headaches, you might find my guide helpful: How to Install a Smart Lock (For When It’s Not as Easy as the YouTube Videos).
My Simple Opinion: Is the Schlage Encode Plus Right for You (like it was for me)?
I see the Schlage Encode Plus for the person who is exactly like me: you’re over keys, you’re an Apple user, and you see this as a permanent security upgrade, not a temporary toy.
You’re not just buying a lock — you’re buying into a century of trust, and in return, you get the most intuitive, stable, and “it just works” experience I’ve found on the market.
If you are willing to invest in that peace of mind, this is the smart lock I recommend.
I really wish someone had told me this before I installed my first smart lock.
The Bottom Line: Schlage Encode Plus Home Key Review
| 👍 Pros | 👎 Cons |
|---|---|
| Apple Home Key is a Game-Changer: True key-free living with just your watch or iPhone. | Premium Price Tag: It’s a significant investment upfront. |
| Proven Stability: Gold standard for reliability in the HomeKit ecosystem. | Potential Weather Sensitivity: Some users report issues in extreme cold/humidity. |
| Thread Support: Massive battery life extension and near-instant response. | Requires a HomeKit Hub: You need a HomePod Mini or Apple TV for the best experience. |
| Triple Backup: Keypad, app, and a physical key mean you’re never locked out. | Schlage Sense Pro Looming: The new model with UWB is coming, but its stability is unproven. |
Ready for Peace of Mind? Stop worrying about keys and start enjoying the convenience.
The Encode Plus is the best investment you can make in your home security this year.
Yale Assure Lock 2 Plus
We chose the Yale Assure Lock 2 Plus because it combines Apple Home Key convenience, sleek design, and proven reliability from one of the most trusted lock brands. It installs easily, works seamlessly with iPhone and Apple Watch, and delivers smooth day-to-day performance for modern smart homes.
Pros
- Seamless Apple Home Key
- Easy Installation
- Premium Build & Design
- Reliable HomeKit Integration
- Flexible Access Options
- Smart Notifications
Cons
- Battery Drains Too Fast
- Auto-Lock Glitches
- Frustrating Support
Why We Picked It
We chose the Yale Assure Lock 2 Plus because it combines Apple Home Key convenience, sleek design, and proven reliability from one of the most trusted lock brands. It installs easily, works seamlessly with iPhone and Apple Watch, and delivers smooth day-to-day performance for modern smart homes.
Who It’s For
Perfect for Apple users who value simplicity, security, and style. Whether you’re upgrading your condo, rental, or family home, this lock is ideal for anyone who wants quick, key-free access without sacrificing looks or peace of mind.
Specs & Configuration
Apple HomeKit Integration – Control with Siri voice commands, automations, and scenes through HomePod, HomePod mini, or Apple TV.;
Remote Access via Yale Access App – Lock/unlock from anywhere, share entry codes, and receive real-time notifications.;
Keyless Convenience – Create unique passcodes for family, guests, or services;
no more hidden keys.;
Power Reserve Mode – Use your iPhone Home Key for hours even after your phone battery dies.;
Emergency 9V Terminal – Temporarily power the lock if internal batteries are drained.;
Auto-Lock & DoorSense® – Automatically locks and detects if your door is securely closed.;
Technical Specifications Lock Type: Electronic keypad deadbolt;
Control Methods: App, Touch, Voice;
Connectivity: Bluetooth + Wi-Fi (built-in, no external module required);
Compatible Voice Assistants: Apple Siri, Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant;
Controller Compatibility: iOS, Android, Apple HomeKit;
Power Source: 4× AA batteries (with Power Reserve + 9V emergency backup);
Finish Options: Satin Nickel, Black Suede, Oil-Rubbed Bronze;
Installation: Fits standard US doors, easy retrofit (no hardwiring needed);
System Requirements For Apple Home Keys: iPhone XS or later (iOS 15+), Apple Watch Series 4 or later (watchOS 8+);
For Multi-User Home Key Sharing: Requires Apple TV, HomePod, or HomePod mini as home hub.
Table Summary: Comparison of Yale Assure 2 Plus advantages and drawbacks — premium design and installation ease versus reliability complaints.
What If You Need an Alternative?
While the Encode Plus is my top pick, I know it’s a premium investment.
If you’re looking for a slightly more budget-friendly option that still plays well with Apple, or if you need a different form factor, here are two smart alternatives I’ve personally looked into:
- Yale Assure Lock 2 Plus: A great option if you prefer a sleeker, smaller design. It also supports HomeKit and Thread, but honestly, I found the Home Key experience on the Schlage to be just a hair more consistent.
- Aqara U100: A fantastic budget option that includes a fingerprint reader—a huge plus for quick entry. It also supports Home Key and is a surprisingly solid performer for the price.
Aqara Smart Lock U100
It delivers rare versatility for its price — combining Apple Home Key, fingerprint access, keypad entry, and solid build quality in one sleek device.
Pros
- Fast Fingerprint Reader
- Apple Home Key Ready
- Many Unlock Options
- Solid Build Quality
- Strong Connectivity
- Quick Setup .
Cons
- Inconsistent Connectivity
- Battery Drain in Harsh Weather
- App & Support Frustrations .
Why We Picked It
It delivers rare versatility for its price — combining Apple Home Key, fingerprint access, keypad entry, and solid build quality in one sleek device.
Who It’s For
Perfect for Apple users and busy families who want multiple secure, convenient ways to unlock their door — from fingerprints to iPhones — without dealing with complex setups or overpriced hardware.
Specs & Configuration
Fingerprint and More Ways to Unlock;
Automations with Aqara and Third-Party Devices;
Auto Lock & Do Not Disturb Mode;
A Durable and Secure Biometric door Lock with Long Battery Life;
Table Summary: Detailed summary of Aqara U100 performance — versatile, well-built smart lock with value pricing and limited weather resilience.
Explore Other Options If the Encode Plus isn’t quite right, or you want to compare prices, check out my full list of recommendations. See My Full List of Recommended Smart Locks for 2026.
